Citizen Green: Should it be Griffinboro or Carrolltown?

15
267
An attempt by state Sen. Trudy Wade (left) to overhaul Greensboro elections has been declared unconstitutional.

Jordan Greenby Jordan Green

There are a couple things we know about the purpose behind state Sen. Trudy Wade’s bill to redistrict Greensboro City Council.

Roy Carroll, the developer responsible for CenterPointe and Bellemeade Village, along with legions of shopping centers, subdivisions and apartment complexes, is for it. He wrote last week in the Rhino Times, the newspaper he owns that acts as a mouthpiece for his business interests, that he likes the plan because it gives the mayor veto power, reduces the size of city government and geographically disperses representation.

He also told News & Record Editorial Editor Allen Johnson that he wants to see “some larger-business managers and owners” serve on city council. The smaller size — seven voting council members, with a mayor able to vote to break the rare tie and able to veto decisions — would make the job more appealing. Carroll told Johnson that business people have told him in the past: “Well, you’ve got nine people up there. I would rather be part of a smaller group of decision makers because in my company we have a management team of four or five people.”

Councils in small Southern cities — like Greensboro and Winston-Salem — were typically run by tight networks of businessmen in the 1950s. They operated with quiet efficiency and consensus, making decisions that typically promoted the interests of big business while avoiding clamorous public debate. Back then they were all elected at large. Since the mid-1980s, Greensboro has had a hybrid system that gives each voter the ability to vote for five out of nine members: the mayor, three at large members and a district representative.

The proposed structure would move Greensboro to a pure district system. While African Americans, including the Rev. Nelson Johnson and Carolina Peacemaker Editor Afrique Kilimanjaro have vocally denounced the plan, it’s an ironic twist that the city’s African-American leadership initially sought a pure representative system to maximize black voting power. Kilimanjaro noted in a recent article that African Americans have developed a potent political alliance with white progressives in Greensboro over the years. This local plan resembles the GOP’s 2011 legislative redistricting effort, which increased black representation, but diluted black political power by driving a wedge between black lawmakers and progressive white allies.

Among the few black leaders to embrace the plan is Skip Alston, a former state NAACP president and real-estate broker who extols the concept of “silver rights.” Incidentally, Alston was soundly whipped by Gladys Robinson in the Democratic primary for state Senate District 28 — a contest in which Alston charged that Robinson was ineffective because she couldn’t work with Republican lawmakers like Wade.

Who really wants this plan? Dozens of people filed before the Guilford County legislative delegation in council chambers at the Melvin Municipal Building last week to reject Wade’s bill, with only four people, including one who doesn’t even live in the city, speaking in favor of it. After the meeting, Wade said “a lot of people who don’t want their names known” are in favor of the plan, adding that they want to remain anonymous “because they fear reprisals and having their names in blogs.” (Do people still blog?)

I asked Wade why she thought it was appropriate for her to sponsor legislation to redistrict Greensboro City Council when only about 20 percent of the city lies in her Senate district. She replied, “I’ll listen to anybody who brings something forward as a constituent.”

Carroll incidentally lives in heavily Democratic District 28 — represented by Robinson — covering 57.7 percent of the city. Such is the plight of being a lonely, rich guy attempting to build an empire in the center city that Carroll must go to a neighboring district in the gerrymandered system created by the anti-urban GOP to get representation.

Robert Corriher nailed it when he predicted at the forum that Wade is unlikely to listen to Greensboro residents, and then turned to address his remarks to the audience in council chambers. Wade’s redistricting effort falls in line with an initiative by the American Legislative Exchange Council — the “dating service” between corporations and conservative politicians more commonly known as ALEC — to turn its attention to municipal government, he said.

“What they’re gonna do is have a fire sale on services that are provided in Greensboro,” Corriher said. “And that’s what she’s here to do.”

While there’s no evidence of linkages between Wade and ALEC or its local offshoot the American City County Exchange, the idea is not as farfetched as it sounds.

Though individuals associated with Kotis Properties — company president Marty Kotis opposes the redistricting plan — and beverage wholesaler RH Barringer contributed $16,060 and $7,000 respectively to Wade’s last campaign, the company with the largest aggregate contribution is DH Griffin, at $19,700. (Carroll contributed a total of $5,300.)

DH Griffin was an investor in a company that was in line to win a contract to operate the White Street Landfill in northeast Greensboro in 2011, before citizens voted in a new city council that withdrew the wildly unpopular plan proposed by Wade and others to reopen the landfill. (Landon Johnson, a spokesman for DH Griffin Companies, said that to his knowledge no one from the company has reached out to Wade to request changes to the city’s election system.)

Consider that when people only have the opportunity to vote for one representative and a mayor, they tend to be less politically engaged. They’re more likely to focus on parochial issues like trash pickup and police coverage than big-picture decisions like Roy Carroll closing a downtown street to build a gated community in the heart of the city. And when fewer people vote, money goes further to buy elections.

Roy Carroll can at least hope.

Related Posts

  • Billy Jones

    It’s funny that Jordan Green asks if people still blog being that I’m reading this on a wordpress W3 Edge blog platform ( http://www.w3-edge/com/wordpress-plugins/ ) RSS feed, comment form and all.

  • I was thinking the same thing Billy. The first thing I noticed was “this is a blog and not a real news story”

    • Yep, they so desperately feel the need to be better than someone– anyone else.

    • Dan

      Actually, it’s a regular column in a paper transcribed to a website utilizing a blogging platform. Brian is right when he says this is as much of a blog as the NYT is.

      • I’m sure Brian and company would like for you to believe that, Dan but if you got to the front page https://triad-city-beat.com/ of this “paper transcribed to a website utilizing a blogging platform” and scroll down you’ll quickly realize that Brian and crew Blog every day while littering once a week. The evidence is in the time and date stamps. Brian comparing himself to the NYT is any way shape or form is laughable. After all, it was my blog that was the only media outlet in the world to report hard numbers on Trudy’s Bill: http://greensboroperformingarts.blogspot.com/2015/02/trudy-wades-district-4-26-of-those-who.html and here http://greensboroperformingarts.blogspot.com/2015/02/registered-voter-percent-of-trudy-wade.html

        Who do you think does the real journalism in Greensboro– the media all cozy with the local politicians? Hasn’t happened in years. Clarey should be proud to blog.

        • Brian Clarey

          We are truly standing on the shoulders of giants.

          • Well Brian, actually the NYT isn’t afraid of admitting that they have blogs http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/blogs/directory.html?_r=0 and use them regularly but apparently You, Jordan and Eric still feel the need to be better than someone, anyone else.

            Standing on the shoulders of giants? Hoping not to get stepped on is more like it. Step up, Brian, show us your strengths. Be brave enough to give us attribution when it’s due, show the rest of Greensboro’s media you’re better than they are. Then you’ll earn our respect. I give every other media outlet in Greensboro stories– scoops- regularly. Wouldn’t you like some too?

            The stick and the carrot, my specialty and I’m on a big one right now that no one else has. Your call,

          • Brian Clarey

            Eat shit, Billy.

          • Well there you have it, I never saw a newspaper editor print the words, “Eat shit, Billy.” This must be a blog.

          • Whatever Billy.

  • I admit that it was a shock to move here from Fayetteville, which has a 9-district/mayor set-up (and it was only in the past few years that the mayor got to vote) and now have a place that I have (in theory, anyway) five representatives on council. Is it the ideal city council makeup? Maybe, maybe not. But, if (as always) may nerd out a bit:

    It sounds like Messr. Carroll hates Madisonian democracy. I’ll admit that some boards can be too big, but if his mystery business leaders who want SO MUCH to run for city council but just can’t because #reasons, then it sounds like they don’t belong in elected politics. There’s 120 members in the NC House and 50 members in the Senate — so should all business leaders stay away from state government? I’m not even going to mention the 435 member US House of Representatives … that must just blow their mind.

    Democracy is … if you want to run (and goodness I assume these mystery folks have the $$ for it), you run, say your message, and let the people decide. …well, unless there’s horrible partisan gerrymandering BUT neither here nor there! But, blah, blah, I vote Carrolltown (it’s like “It’s a Wonderful Life”).

  • I vote for Clarytown; triad City can’t be beat.
    that’s pretty darn professional for a editor.

    • Clareytown gets my vote. Not that I’ve got a problem with Clarey writing “Eat shit, Billy.” and Eric’s “Whatever Billy.” proving Ginsburg also has nothing of substance to add, but then I’m a blogger. ROTFLMAO!