police have at least a dozen people to interview who were potential witnesses
to the shooting death of Julius “Juice” Sampson in the parking lot at Hanes Mall
A Forsyth County superior court
judge ruled that the public will have to wait at least six months to hear 911
recordings from the shooting that took the life of Julius “Juice” Sampson last
Sampson, a 32-year-old black man,
was shot in the parking lot of Hanes Mall in broad daylight on Aug. 6 following
an argument with Robert Anthony Granato, a 22-year-old white man who is charged
with murder. Although Winston-Salem police Chief Catrina Thompson said the
police had uncovered no evidence of a racial motive, allegations that a racial
slur epithet had been used in the argument prompted a social-media firestorm promoting
an unfounded narrative that the city was covering up a racially motivated
Press conferences led by Mayor Allen
Joines, Chief Thompson and Sheriff Bobby Kimbrough, along with a vigil for the
Forsyth County Resident Superior
Court Judge David Hall ruled on Monday that five 911 recordings will remain
under seal. The judge said he respects the news media’s First Amendment right
to report on court proceedings, but was swayed by learning from District
Attorney Jim O’Neill’s office that Winston-Salem police still have at least a
dozen witnesses, including one person who lives out of state, to interview.
“In balancing all of these very
important concerns, in my discretion I do not want to compromise this
investigation,” Hall said. “I do not want to impede, rush the investigation if
there is any putative eye or ear witness who we haven’t heard from.”
Hall agreed with prosecutors that
releasing the recordings could potentially “contaminate” the accounts of
witnesses who have yet to be identified.
“These are people who are giving
contemporaneous accounts, people with information only known to the people who
were there,” said Assistant District Attorney Jennifer Martin. “There are
people who are yet to be interviewed who were inside the restaurant as the
dispute was unfolding.”
The district attorney’s office and
the defendant agreed that the recordings should remain sealed. Hall said his
primary concern was that releasing them could compromise the investigation, but
a secondary concern is that they might be prejudicial to the administration of
justice. Prosecutors seized on that issue to argue that any hint that Granato
wouldn’t receive a fair trial in Forsyth County could result in a change of
venue, causing hardship and inconvenience to Sampson’s family and investigators
who might be called to testify. Granato attended the hearing dressed in an
orange jumpsuit while Sampson’s family sat in the gallery.
Judge Hall said he will hold a
hearing to review the order sealing the 911 recordings on Feb. 26, 2020.
The Winston-Salem Journal and news stations WXII, WFMY and WGHP had
sought the immediate release of the recordings. While the media entities — whom
Judge Hall allowed to intervene in the criminal case as movants — did not get
their wish, their lawyer Hugh Stevens said the scheduled review hearing was
better than having the recordings sealed indefinitely.
“This has been proven to be a good
way to keep track of the matter and not have it fall by the wayside,” he said.
Judge Hall said he will review the
five recordings again and determine whether any parts can be released to the
public without compromising the investigation, but he was doubtful that would
be the case. Meanwhile, Paul James, Granato’s lawyer, suggested he could get
together with lawyers from the district attorney’s office and produce a
transcript of the recordings and potentially release it after submitting it to
detectives for review. Judge Hall indicated that he would have no objections.
District Attorney Jim O’Neill
cautioned that there’s no definitive time period when the recordings could be
released without compromising the investigation.
“When does the investigation end?”
he asked. “The answer is an investigation never really ends…. To say an
investigation will be completed in 60 days would not be true…. The
Winston-Salem Police Department may need to investigate right up to the time of
O’Neill and Martin alluded to homicides that have taken place since Sampson’s death, and the district attorney took a dig at the news media for its focus on the Granato case.
“The chief made a statement that
this case is not about race, but the media has latched on to that narrative,”
O’Neill said. “When we have a child hit in the head while he’s playing with
Play-Doh, we don’t get the same push from the media.”
While not disputing any of the
information relayed in news media coverage, James said some of the “commentary
in the newspaper was not factual,” and that it “muddied” the issues in the
“Mr. O’Neill and I are both
constrained by rules of professional conduct, and we don’t try cases in the
media,” James said. “So we read things that are not true, but we can’t say,
‘That’s bloody wrong.’”
Stevens defended his clients’
editorial judgment in covering the story.
“When the mayor holds a press
conference, we cover it,” he said. “When the chief of police holds a press
conference, we cover it. When the sheriff holds a press conference, we cover
it. When people are upset and they hold a vigil, it’s a story. We respond to
events when they unfold. What my clients are trying to do is let the public
know everything they can without prejudicing either side. I make no apologies
for the coverage. The coverage is there because it’s an important matter, and
other people have made it an important matter.”
While upholding the order to seal
the 911 recordings, Judge Hall validated the legitimacy of news coverage of the
case. He said he “took judicial notice” of the extraordinary interest and media
coverage in the case, of the various press conferences, the vigil, and the
formation a “Justice for Juice” advocacy group.
“This is an important case,” he
Join the First Amendment Society, a membership that goes directly to funding TCB‘s newsroom.
We believe that reporting can save the world.
The TCB First Amendment Society recognizes the vital role of a free, unfettered press with a bundling of local experiences designed to build community, and unique engagements with our newsroom that will help you understand, and shape, local journalism’s critical role in uplifting the people in our cities.
All revenue goes directly into the newsroom as reporters’ salaries and freelance commissions.